


Vol 61, No 2 (2025)
Theoretical and methodological problems
Inflation, economic growth and money supply in a model of the shifting modes of reproduction with a continuous set of subsystems
Abstract
The model of switching modes of reproduction (SMR) is a heterodox model of endogenous growth in continuous time with a finite number of overlapping generations of capital and a monetary sector. A distinctive feature of the SMR model is that the long-run neutrality of money is violated in the model. The aim of this paper is to advance our understanding of the internal mechanisms of the SMR model, to qualitatively describe the macroeconomic effects present in the model, and to examine how monetary policy affects growth and inflation in it. The original SRM models do not allow closed-form solutions due to their complex structure and therefore, theoretical analysis based on the SRM models is limited to the study of particular numerical solutions. The article considers the author’s version of the SRM model with a continuous set of capital generations, for which, under the assumption that growth is stationary, an approximate explicit solution of the model is derived. It is shown that the increase of the money supply growth rate has a positive effect on inflation, while the effect on economic growth is non-monotonous. We analyse how economic growth and inflation depend on all the other exogenous variables and interpret the dependences explaining the economic mechanisms providing the outcomes. Three regimes of monetary policy are studied: the policy of maximizing growth, the policy of ensuring price stability, and the policy of a compromise between growth and inflation, which involves optimization by the ratio of gross inflation to gross output growth rates. We critically discuss the assumptions underlying the SRM model and the role of these assumptions in the violation of money neutrality in the model as well as the other results.



World economy
The phenomenon of “economic miracles”: Reassessing historical experience
Abstract
The paper presents comparative analysis of macroeconomic policies in various countries (in Europe, Asia, North and South America) that had periods of long-term economic growth within the time range between 1933 and 2019. The analysis focuses on different measures adopted by governments of these countries with the aim of making an economic breakthrough and setting a country on a new path of development. The research demonstrates that completely oppose measures proved effective in different countries at different points in time. Some states enhanced government intervention in the economy, while others fostered economic liberalization. In some countries industrial concentration took place, whereas in others mainly small and medium-sized enterprises received support from the government. The same applies to improvement/deterioration in labour standards. Therefore, it is incorrect to try to build an economic system by merely copying foreign experience in order to foster socio-economic and technological development. The above-mentioned thesis is confirmed by referring to the historical experience of thirteen countries. There are, however, traits that countries that experienced long-term economic growth have in common. All of them conducted expansionary macroeconomic policy, supported key economic sectors (primarily agriculture and heavy industry), introduced breakthrough and incremental innovations, made investments in infrastructure, stimulated exports as well as accumulated social capital.



Problems of national economy
Domestic and foreign knowledge as determinants of innovation export
Abstract
The quality of a country’s economic growth is mainly determined by the ability and capacity of its companies to create and use new knowledge. Creating new knowledge, companies often have to absorb the external knowledge. Knowledge from sources located in countries with higher levels of technological development can play an important role in narrowing the technological gap with these countries. However, foreign knowledge acquisition, especially when domestic firms’ own knowledge base and absorptive capacity are low, can lead to a technological trap. The study aimed to determine whether changes in the use of in-house and external knowledge from foreign sources occur in the process of creating high-degree novelty innovations by the Russian organizations. The novelty of innovations was defined, on the one hand, as the technological novelty of the new products and services, and on the other hand, as their demand in foreign markets. A multinomial regression model was built, in which different levels of the share of the total value of exports of high technological novelty innovations were considered as the dependent variable. As a result, it was found that the majority of domestic enterprises that exported innovations fell into the trap of imitation. However, a small part of companies in certain regions that contributed most to the value of exports, unlike the majority, relied more on their own knowledge base and successfully integrated foreign knowledge into it. The paper proposes some measures aimed at the development of Russian innovative firms’ own knowledge base.



Dynamics of macroeconomic indicators in Russia: Wavelet analysis of unemployment, inflation and interest rates
Abstract
This article proposes a wavelet analysis of the dynamics of three key macroeconomic indicators in the Russian economy: unemployment, inflation and interest rates for the period from 1990 to 2021. The analysis of the dynamics of key macroeconomic indicators in the Russian economy was carried out using wavelet analysis in combination with tests for stationarity of time series, such as the extended Dickey–Fuller test, Phillips–Perron test, Granger test and Quach–Perron test. The analysis shows that in Russia there are no parameters relevant of Phillips curve during the period under review, and the inverse relationship between the inflation rate and the unemployment rate is not confirmed. However, there is a relationship between the interest rate and inflation, as well as between the interest rate and the unemployment rate, although the nature of these relationships varies over different time periods. The study revealed changes in the temporal dynamics of these indicators at different time frequencies (low and high). In particular, a statistically significant relationship between unemployment and inflation was found at low frequencies, where unemployment peaks began to precede inflation peaks from 2009 and onwards. At high frequencies, there is a time shift between the interest rate and inflation after 1998, as well as a negative shift between the interest rate and unemployment during certain time periods. These results help to better understand long-term trends and relationships in the Russian economy, and also have practical implications for the formation of economic policy.



Regional problems
Integral structural complexity index of regional economies
Abstract
Current scientific discussions are focused on identifying professions and types of economic activity that will become most in demand in the future and determine priority areas for diversification of regional economies. Analysis of such trends is important for forecasting the dynamics of GRP. The purpose of this work is to construct an integral index of structural complexity on the basis of four basic indices of economic complexity of regional economies, calculated by the authors on the basis of data on the structure of employment, the structure of the distribution of enterprises and the structure of GRP. According to Rosstat for 2019 and 2022, four basic complexity indices were formed for 85 regions: the index of complexity of GRP structures based on data on production by types of economic activity (TEA); index of complexity of employment structures of the regions by TEA; index of regional employment structures by occupational groups; index of complexity of distribution structures of enterprises in the regions by TEA. The analysis of 0–1 matrices for all four economic complexity indices under consideration is carried out. The leading positions in the four corresponding ratings are occupied by Moscow, St. Petersburg, the Novosibirsk Region, and the Moscow Region. Four integral indices of structural complexity of regional economies were constructed. Their advantages and disadvantages are analyzed. It is shown that the structural complexity of the regional economy has an impact on GRP. Moreover, one of the integral indices is significant in the production function of the GRP of 85 regions according to the data of 2019 and 2022.



Impact of key interest rate changes on mortgage rates in Russian regions
Abstract
The article considers the interest rate channel of the monetary policy transmission of the Bank of Russia to the weighted average mortgage rate published on the website of the Bank of Russia and the “commercial” mortgage rate calculated by us less mortgage programmes: preferential, family, Far East, Arctic and mortgage programme for IT specialists. The main hypothesis tested in the article was the reaction of mortgage rates to changes in monetary policy of the Bank of Russia; it varied by Russian regions and by time intervals. To test this hypothesis, we used an error correction model (ECM), estimated on monthly data for 85 Russian regions from January 2016 to August 2023. The results showed that before COVID-19 (January 2016 — February 2020), a long-term relationship of mortgage rates with Moscow Interbank Actual Credit Rate (MIACR) and adjustment to long-term equilibrium were found in most regions (76 regions for weighted average and 61 regions for commercial rates). COVID-19 impacted the transmission of both weighted average rates and commercial rates approximately equally, in the period January 2016 — February 2022 it remained in 4 and 14 Russian regions, respectively. The special military operation (SMO) shock (estimated on the data up to August 2023) stronger influenced the transmission of weighted average rates than commercial rates (it remained in 5 and 30 regions, respectively). Monetary transmission is a set of channels for transmitting impulses of changes in the key rate of the central bank to the volume of liquidity and economic activity of agents. Impact of monetary policy on mortgage rates varied by regions: before COVID-19 — in the European part of Russia, weighted average mortgage rates reacted to the change in MIACR mainly in the month after the shock and in Siberia and the Far East — in the next month, which may be caused by multiple intermediaries.



Regional effects of fiscal policy: Analysis with spatial vector autoregressive models
Abstract
This paper attempts to assess the impact of fiscal policy measures conducted in Russian Federation units on gross regional product. For this purpose, we use panel data for 80 Russian regions for 2005–2020. As a method for assessing the response of GRP to the shock of government expenditures, we propose to use a spatial vector autoregression model consisting of three equations for the following endogenous variables: GRP, consolidated budget expenditures, tax revenues. The model also includes a set of exogenous factors: oil prices, MIACR interest rate, expenditures of the Russian Pension Fund. Additionally, we account for the structure of the regional economy. The advantage of the model is the ability to simultaneously consider spatial effects using the contiguity-based matrix and evaluate the impulse response function, while the Cholesky decomposition is used for shock identification. Overall, we estimated 3 SpVAR specifications and considered shocks of government expenditures for 7 categories of regional budgets. The main result of the study is the peak and cumulative values of IRF for 2 and 3 years, which reflect the evolution of the GRP response to an exogenous shock of expenditures over time. For all specifications of the model, the greatest positive effect on GRP is observed for the shock of expenditures on the national economy and education. Depending on the specification, over 3 years after the shock of increasing expenditures by 1%, an expected increase in GRP varies from 0.053 to 0.1% and from 0.051 to 0.1%, respectively.



Проблемы предприятий
Using quasi-experimental methods for quantitative research of government policies’ measures of SMB support
Abstract
In this work we analyze methodologies that are used in research to obtain estimates of policies efficiency and will show how Propensity Score Methods can be adopted to the given scarce data on the case of Russian loan guarantee program. We take number of workers employed in Russian SMEs as a target metric; an aim to increase this number to 25 ml workers which is claimed in Russia’s national development goals. The study suggests methods for matching PSM propensity scores that can be applied to obtain an assessment of the effectiveness of a specific government measure. These methods, along with two-stage Heckman regression and panel data models for multi-period Difference-in-Difference expansion, seem to be the most suitable for evaluating the effect of intervention and reducing sampling error. The estimates obtained on the basis of this methodology indicate a significant positive effect of issuing guarantees in terms of increasing employment. Also we highlighted industries with the most positive average treatment effect from the program. Those policy measures the efficiency of which was proved by quantitative research need to be promoted more actively than less efficient measures: authorities need to reduce obstacles that beneficiaries can face to receive government support, to increase financing, to improve SMEs’ awareness of such policy measures.



Mathematical analysis of economic models
The effectiveness of the main information criteria in choosing the best short-term economic forecasting model
Abstract
Any theory is based on a certain axiomatic core, which includes axioms and postulates. The latter includes conclusions and results from other theories or branches of science that are accepted in this theory without proof. Among such postulates accepted in modern economic forecasting are informational criteria, which are used to select the best forecasting model from a set of competing ones. Most often, forecasters use two main criteria — Akaike and Schwarz. The article demonstrates, using the example of short-term forecasting of 120 different data series through AR(p) autoregressions, that in practice this tool does not perform as well as expected. An alternative to the informational criteria can be a criterion based on Bayesian hypothesis testing, which is outlined in the article. This criterion incorporates information about the likelihood of describing prior and posterior data, the cross-accounting of which corresponds to Bayesian selection. A comparative analysis of the application of informational criteria and the new criterion, the results of which are presented in the article, supports the latter criterion, which is recommended for practical use.



Wavelet analysis of the relationship between energy prices and stock indices of high ESG-rating companies: Investment diversification opportunities
Abstract
Our research is the first attempt to identify relationships between «Brent» oil and natural gas prices and indices of stocks of companies with high ESG-ratings (ESG-leaders) in the time and frequency domains. We use such methods in the wavelet analysis framework as analysis of quadratic wavelet coherence and phase difference between data series. Our study is based on daily data from 2018 to the beginning of 2024, which allows us to cover periods of relative macroeconomic stability (until 2020), the COVID-19 coronavirus pandemic (2020–2021) and growing geopolitical tensions in the world (from 2022). We consider ESG-indices of the global market, US and EU markets. Our study shows areas of low and high consistency between energy prices and ESG-leaders’ indices for the three periods under examination and identifies lag and lead relationships between the two considered asset classes. Identifying areas of low consistency allows an investor to develop investment diversification strategies, including hedging against drops in oil and gas prices during global crises. We find that global and US ESG-leaders’ indices provide opportunities for diversifying investments in natural gas futures.


